Research Methodologies

May 3, 2013

Does Quantification In Market Research Lead To Disengagement?

Edward Appleton on the potential implications of behavioral economics for quantitative research.

Edward Appleton

by Edward Appleton

Director Global Marketing at Happy Thinking People

0

 

Learning numbers

 

By Edward Appleton

Week 6 of the Dan Ariely/Duke University Behavioral Economics (BE) online course (http://bit.ly/ZzUmWh ) is about Emotions; one of the first reading assignments focuses on a phenomenon called “Psychic Numbing”.

A term originally coined in the 1960s, this refers to a cognitive process of disengagement, a numbing of feeling, induced by the use of numbers. It leads to apathy and inaction. To quote the authors:

“Numerical representations of human lives do not necessarily convey the importance of …. lives.”

My mind immediately flew to Quant. Research, Predictive Analytics and Big Data.

The actual article – (http://bit.ly/10VxR14) authored jointly by Paul Slovic, David Zionts, Andrew K. Woods, Ryan Goodman,and Derek Jinks – addresses the apathy often witnessed towards mass atrocity and shows how psychologically engagement falls off the moment we start to portray a problem simply in terms of numbers. We engage far more actively, process information more effectively, when confronted with individual stories and narratives. Presenting “numbers” results in a “blurring of individuals” (Annie Dillard) – a phenomenon that can begin with as few as 2 people. Scary.

This BE finding has potential implications for Quantitative Research, especially in terms of how data is presented. Many quant. read-outs are concerned with measurability, statistics, percentages, sample sizes. They are seldom (never?) accompanied by a focus on the individuals making up the sample. Maybe we’re missing a trick. Here’s my take, borrowing from some of the implications outlined in the Article:

1. Building in Individual Experiences can Greatly Enrich a Quant. Survey.

Many straight quantitative surveys have some open-ended questions, requiring individuals to do more than tick a box. But how many actually ask respondents to share visuals with us to show us what they mean? Given the growing use of mobile, maybe we should ask participants to use their smartphones or tablets to take pictures more. This would give a quant. survey a qualitative feel without being truly qual./quant – and the de-brief would be much more engaging.

2. Counter “Numbing” by Emotionally Priming an Audience Prior to a Debrief

I’ve never tried this, but it’s an interesting idea. The article suggests priming audiences to “feel” prior to looking at any numbers – simply asking them to describe their feelings when thinking of something emotional, eg a baby. Translating this to a product category – easier for higher-involvement B2C areas, but not impossible even for low-interest products – might make a potentially “challenging” (strenuous, long) de-brief on a given commercial area a more engaged, emotionalized experience.

3. Use Imagery – but avoid Cliches.

Visualizing can be a powerful narrative technique, but using well worn images is invariably counterproductive, leading to swifter disengagement.

4. Anticipate Co-Creating Indicated Actions with Your Stakeholders

The authors suggest that faced with the danger of psychic numbing, building in a session focused purely on decision-making will heighten engagement and heighten the likelihood of action being taken. They call it a “deliberation-enforcing approach”. For researchers, it’s something worth considering – building an interactive, action-focused workshop session into a quant. debrief. 

Combining the insights of a qualitative survey with the robustness of a quantitative project is for me at least a sort of Holy Grail of Market Research. Maybe incorporating some of the above helps take us a step in that direction.

Curious, as ever, as to others’ views.

0

behavioral economicsquantitative researchrespondent engagement

Disclaimer

The views, opinions, data, and methodologies expressed above are those of the contributor(s) and do not necessarily reflect or represent the official policies, positions, or beliefs of Greenbook.

Comments

Comments are moderated to ensure respect towards the author and to prevent spam or self-promotion. Your comment may be edited, rejected, or approved based on these criteria. By commenting, you accept these terms and take responsibility for your contributions.

More from Edward Appleton

Interview with Deborah Ancona: Seley Distinguished Professor

Research Methodologies

Interview with Deborah Ancona: Seley Distinguished Professor

Qualitative Research takes the front seat in this interview with Deborah Ancona.

Edward Appleton

Edward Appleton

Director Global Marketing at Happy Thinking People

Is There a Difference Between Consumer Insights and Market Research?

Insights Industry News

Is There a Difference Between Consumer Insights and Market Research?

Edward Appleton explores the difference between research and insights.

Edward Appleton

Edward Appleton

Director Global Marketing at Happy Thinking People

Edward Appleton’s Impressions of #IIeX EU 2017

Edward Appleton shares what stood out at last week’s IIeX Europe.

Edward Appleton

Edward Appleton

Director Global Marketing at Happy Thinking People

A Renaissance of Qualitative Research

We’re witnessing not just a renaissance of qualitative research, we’re seeing a transformation.

Edward Appleton

Edward Appleton

Director Global Marketing at Happy Thinking People

ARTICLES

Moving Away from a Narcissistic Market Research Model

Research Methodologies

Moving Away from a Narcissistic Market Research Model

Why are we still measuring brand loyalty? It isn’t something that naturally comes up with consumers, who rarely think about brand first, if at all. Ma...

Devora Rogers

Devora Rogers

Chief Strategy Officer at Alter Agents

The Stepping Stones of Innovation: Navigating Failure and Empathy with Carol Fitzgerald
Natalie Pusch

Natalie Pusch

Senior Content Producer at Greenbook

Sign Up for
Updates

Get what matters, straight to your inbox.
Curated by top Insight Market experts.

67k+ subscribers

Weekly Newsletter

Greenbook Podcast

Webinars

Event Updates

I agree to receive emails with insights-related content from Greenbook. I understand that I can manage my email preferences or unsubscribe at any time and that Greenbook protects my privacy under the General Data Protection Regulation.*