Brand Strategy

July 7, 2016

Skin In The Game: Revealing The Honest Truth

Skin in the game is a powerful concept and is necessary to understand true human reality.

Anouar El

by Anouar El

Founder & Chief Executive Officer at Veylinx

0

skininthegame

 

By Anouar El Haji

There’s data, and there’s data. The most challenging type of data is data collected from people. It’s challenging in the sense that it’s hard to verify whether what people claim to value and believe is true. For example, Bob might say he prefers coffee to tea but there’s no way to be sure—he alone knows whether this is really the case.

To reveal what Bob truly prefers, we should present him the real option to be served either coffee or tea and observe his preferred drinking choice. Bob is now much less likely to misrepresent his actual preference because he’ll have to bear the consequences of consuming his choice. This is called having ‘skin in the game’.

If you have skin in the game it means that you expose yourself to the real consequences of your claims; positive or negative. Skin in the game ensures that your statements and actions are aligned with your true preferences and beliefs. It’s no surprise that people who have skin in the game are taken more seriously than those who don’t. A recent study shows that stock analysts (whose job is to figure out which shares to buy or sell) are considered more trustworthy if they follow their own advice while analysts who have no skin in the game are mostly ignored.

Here’s the problem though: most data is collected from people who have zero skin in the game. Whether it’s collecting data using surveys, social media, focus groups or interviews, data without skin in the game is at worst simply wrong, and at best doubtful. That’s quite alarming because a lot of decision-making, both in the public and private sector, depends on this type of data.

In the academic community, especially among behavioral economists, this problem is well understood. For this reason experiments in which participants have skin in the game are considered much more trustworthy. To illustrate this point researchers asked participants whether they would be willing to donate $8 to a college scholarship fund—hypothetically speaking. The participants were explicitly asked to imagine that the choice is real. A clear majority of 71% claimed ‘Yes’. Afterwards, however, the very same participants were asked whether they would be actually willing to donate $8 to the fund. The percentage of participants who said ‘Yes’ dropped all the way to 38%!

Skin in the game is a powerful concept and is necessary to understand true human reality. High-impact recommendations that are not based on reliable data can have far reaching negative consequences for business and society. The increasing availability of data is actually harmful if the data cannot be relied on. In fact, more spurious data just leads to more doubtful conclusions. Data with skin in the game is not a luxury but a necessity.

0

Disclaimer

The views, opinions, data, and methodologies expressed above are those of the contributor(s) and do not necessarily reflect or represent the official policies, positions, or beliefs of Greenbook.

Comments

Comments are moderated to ensure respect towards the author and to prevent spam or self-promotion. Your comment may be edited, rejected, or approved based on these criteria. By commenting, you accept these terms and take responsibility for your contributions.

More from Anouar El

Inflation Reveals the Need for Better Insights

Consumer Behavior

Inflation Reveals the Need for Better Insights

A focus on consumer demand is needed to offset rising inflation.

Anouar El

Anouar El

Founder & Chief Executive Officer at Veylinx

Consumer Behavior

Defining ‘Value’ to Understand What Makes People Tick

Knowing what people value most, provides us with the information to create as much value as possible.

Anouar El

Anouar El

Founder & Chief Executive Officer at Veylinx

Research Methodologies

The Elusive Gold Standard In Market Research

The method that gets closest to consumer behavior should be considered the gold standard in market research.

Anouar El

Anouar El

Founder & Chief Executive Officer at Veylinx

ARTICLES

Moving Away from a Narcissistic Market Research Model

Research Methodologies

Moving Away from a Narcissistic Market Research Model

Why are we still measuring brand loyalty? It isn’t something that naturally comes up with consumers, who rarely think about brand first, if at all. Ma...

Devora Rogers

Devora Rogers

Chief Strategy Officer at Alter Agents

The Stepping Stones of Innovation: Navigating Failure and Empathy with Carol Fitzgerald
Natalie Pusch

Natalie Pusch

Senior Content Producer at Greenbook

Sign Up for
Updates

Get what matters, straight to your inbox.
Curated by top Insight Market experts.

67k+ subscribers

Weekly Newsletter

Greenbook Podcast

Webinars

Event Updates

I agree to receive emails with insights-related content from Greenbook. I understand that I can manage my email preferences or unsubscribe at any time and that Greenbook protects my privacy under the General Data Protection Regulation.*